..City of Settlers

..Migration stories in personal photographs

City of Settlers

Migration stories in personal photographs

Editorial
Story behind City of Settlers
Welcome to City of Settlers, a collection of personal migration stories from new Bishkekians. Before you begin this journey, I’d like to take a moment to share the personal motivation behind this project.

My name is Lilit Dabagian, and I am the creator of City of Settlers. Paradoxically, for a project about migration to Bishkek, I have never experienced moving to Kyrgyzstan’s capital - or even changing my address within the city. I grew up in the heart of Bishkek, in the same apartment where my family has lived for seventy-two years. Needless to say, this shaped my deep-rooted sense of being a Bishkekian.

Last year, I moved to Berlin. As a farewell gift, my mother gave me a photo album filled with images of different family members. The family photo album opens with the oldest picture taken in a photo studio in Van in the eastern Ottoman Empire in early 1915. A family of six - four children of different ages, a mother in an ornate gown sitting on the left, and a father in a fez on the right. The second photo was taken fifteen years later in a Tbilisi studio. The same couple is dressed modestly this time. The woman no longer wears a sumptuous dress but a simple outfit with a headscarf, and the man’s fez is gone. These are my great-great-grandparents - refugees from the Ottoman Empire who resettled in Tbilisi. Their grandson would later move to Yerevan as a repatriated Armenian, and his son - my father - would decide to leave Yerevan for Bishkek to join my mother after the Soviet Union dissolved.
The oldest photo from my mother’s side, dating back to 1938, is a studio photograph of a 15-year-old girl (my grandmother) who had recently arrived in Frunze (now Bishkek) from the village of Jon-Aryk near Karabalta. Born into a poor Kyrgyz family in a yurt, she was the first in her family to attend school. But at fifteen, her parents insisted she leave school to help at home - and likely prepare for future marriage. On the way back from collecting her school certificates, she stopped at the train station, mesmerized by the locomotive. Whether it was curiosity about a train she had never ridden or a desire to escape the life that awaited her in the village, she made a spontaneous decision to board the train and see where it would take her. The train headed to Frunze.

Looking at these photos, I realized something strikingly obvious. Despite my deep-rooted sense of belonging in Bishkek, migration has been woven into my family’s history. That realization made me wonder: How much of Bishkek’s history is, in fact, a history of migration?

My family’s story includes both urban migration - from a village to the capital - and international migration to Bishkek. With City of Settlers, I wanted to bring these two types of migration together - two experiences often seen as separate or even opposed. What happens when we look for shared themes in different migration stories? What do they reveal about arriving, settling, adapting, or perhaps not adapting to Bishkek? And what can internal and external migration stories tell us about the kind of city Bishkek is?
Editorial
Story behind City of Settlers
Welcome to City of Settlers, a collection of personal migration stories from new Bishkekians. Before you begin this journey, I’d like to take a moment to share the personal motivation behind this project.

My name is Lilit Dabagian, and I am the creator of City of Settlers. Paradoxically, for a project about migration to Bishkek, I have never experienced moving to Kyrgyzstan’s capital - or even changing my address within the city. I grew up in the heart of Bishkek, in the same apartment where my family has lived for seventy-two years. Needless to say, this shaped my deep-rooted sense of being a Bishkekian.

Last year, I moved to Berlin. As a farewell gift, my mother gave me a photo album filled with images of different family members. The family photo album opens with the oldest picture taken in a photo studio in Van in the eastern Ottoman Empire in early 1915. A family of six - four children of different ages, a mother in an ornate gown sitting on the left, and a father in a fez on the right. The second photo was taken fifteen years later in a Tbilisi studio. The same couple is dressed modestly this time. The woman no longer wears a sumptuous dress but a simple outfit with a headscarf, and the man’s fez is gone. These are my great-great-grandparents - refugees from the Ottoman Empire who resettled in Tbilisi. Their grandson would later move to Yerevan as a repatriated Armenian, and his son - my father - would decide to leave Yerevan for Bishkek to join my mother after the Soviet Union dissolved.
The oldest photo from my mother’s side, dating back to 1938, is a studio photograph of a 15-year-old girl (my grandmother) who had recently arrived in Frunze (now Bishkek) from the village of Jon-Aryk near Karabalta. Born into a poor Kyrgyz family in a yurt, she was the first in her family to attend school. But at fifteen, her parents insisted she leave school to help at home - and likely prepare for future marriage. On the way back from collecting her school certificates, she stopped at the train station, mesmerized by the locomotive. Whether it was curiosity about a train she had never ridden or a desire to escape the life that awaited her in the village, she made a spontaneous decision to board the train and see where it would take her. The train headed to Frunze.

Looking at these photos, I realized something strikingly obvious. Despite my deep-rooted sense of belonging in Bishkek, migration has been woven into my family’s history. That realization made me wonder: How much of Bishkek’s history is, in fact, a history of migration?

My family’s story includes both urban migration - from a village to the capital - and international migration to Bishkek. With City of Settlers, I wanted to bring these two types of migration together - two experiences often seen as separate or even opposed. What happens when we look for shared themes in different migration stories? What do they reveal about arriving, settling, adapting, or perhaps not adapting to Bishkek? And what can internal and external migration stories tell us about the kind of city Bishkek is?
Stories you'll find here
Overview of City of Settlers multimedia zine
In this multimedia zine, you will dive into the migration stories of people who moved to Bishkek—some from other parts of Kyrgyzstan, such as Talas, Uzgen, and Tereksay, and others from countries like Taiwan, Russia, and the U.S. Despite the diverse circumstances surrounding their migration, unexpected similarities emerge between these experiences. Recurring themes include the search for home, the experience of being an outsider or a stranger, and questions of belonging.

Guliza Urustambek kyzy from Uzgen and Yulia Pogodayeva from Russia examine the idea of making a home through objects. However, their approaches fundamentally differ and are shaped by their professions. Photographer Guliza Urustambek kyzy explores her search for home and comfort through a visual medium, resulting in a compelling photo project. Yulia Pogodayeva, a theater director, also uses photography, but in her case, it serves as a foundation for a text infused with elements of magical realism.
Bermet Malikova from Talas and Huai-Tse Yang from Taiwan center their reflections on language. Bermet Malikova examines how bilingualism shapes her experience of Bishkek, her feelings of being a stranger, and her attempts to build connections in the city. Huai-Tse Yang, an anthropology PhD student, takes an academic approach. In his essay, he looks at his experience as an outsider who tried but "failed" to build bridges with a Uighur community in Bishkek, yet discovered ways to engage with their world indirectly, guided by clues and signs hidden in the language.

Tynymgul Eshieva from Tereksay and Lily Nemirovsky from the U.S. created interactive maps to visualize their search for a place of belonging. Tynymgul Eshieva recounts how Bishkek has gradually become home for her over several decades. Lily Nemirovsky, reflecting on her international background, grapples with the limits and possibilities of belonging to multiple places - and, in this context, explores the question of why Bishkek feels like home.

Now, let me hand it over to the contributors of this project.

Lilit Dabagian

Stories you'll find here
Overview of City of Settlers multimedia zine
In this multimedia zine, you will dive into the migration stories of people who moved to Bishkek—some from other parts of Kyrgyzstan, such as Talas, Uzgen, and Tereksay, and others from countries like Taiwan, Russia, and the U.S. Despite the diverse circumstances surrounding their migration, unexpected similarities emerge between these experiences. Recurring themes include the search for home, the experience of being an outsider or a stranger, and questions of belonging.

Guliza Urustambek kyzy from Uzgen and Yulia Pogodayeva from Russia examine the idea of making a home through objects. However, their approaches fundamentally differ and are shaped by their professions. Photographer Guliza Urustambek kyzy explores her search for home and comfort through a visual medium, resulting in a compelling photo project. Yulia Pogodayeva, a theater director, also uses photography, but in her case, it serves as a foundation for a text infused with elements of magical realism.
Bermet Malikova from Talas and Huai-Tse Yang from Taiwan center their reflections on language. Bermet Malikova examines how bilingualism shapes her experience of Bishkek, her feelings of being a stranger, and her attempts to build connections in the city. Huai-Tse Yang, an anthropology PhD student, takes an academic approach. In his essay, he looks at his experience as an outsider who tried but "failed" to build bridges with a Uighur community in Bishkek, yet discovered ways to engage with their world indirectly, guided by clues and signs hidden in the language.

Tynymgul Eshieva from Tereksay and Lily Nemirovsky from the U.S. created interactive maps to visualize their search for a place of belonging. Tynymgul Eshieva recounts how Bishkek has gradually become home for her over several decades. Lily Nemirovsky, reflecting on her international background, grapples with the limits and possibilities of belonging to multiple places - and, in this context, explores the question of why Bishkek feels like home.

Now, let me hand it over to the contributors of this project.

Lilit Dabagian

Migration stories
#Object #Home: An Object Making One Feel at Home
by Guliza Urustambek kyzy
by Yulia Pogodayeva
Migration stories
#Object #Home: An Object Making One Feel at Home
by Guliza Urustambek kyzy
by Yulia Pogodayeva
#Stranger #Language: Bishkek’s Linguistic Landscape and the Feeling of Being an Outsider
#Stranger #Language: Bishkek’s Linguistic Landscape and the Feeling of Being an Outsider
#SearchForHome #Identity: Finding One’s Place and Self - Can Bishkek Truly Become Home?
by Tynymgul Eshieva
by Lily Nemirovsky
#SearchForHome #Identity: Finding One’s Place and Self - Can Bishkek Truly Become Home?
by Tynymgul Eshieva
by Lily Nemirovsky
The City of Settlers Workshop
Workshop program City of Settlers explored Bishkek’s diverse history, focusing on the migrant experiences of those who have shaped Pishpek, Frunze, and Bishkek. Among them were settled (semi-)nomads, peasants, refugees, evacuees, deportees, factory workers, and students.

Participants were invited to reflect on their journey to Kyrgyzstan's capital while also exploring the microhistories of other residents, uncovering what it meant to be a newcomer to Bishkek at different times. Participants engaged in self-reflective discussions, participated in role-playing activities, and created an imaginary museum of migration, showcasing an array of migration stories.

The workshop City of Settlers took place on November 23, November 30, and December 7.


I would like to express my gratitude to the bookstore "Knizhnaya Lavka" and its owners Anara Moldosheva and Charlie Buxton for generously providing us with the space. I also sincerely thank Alima Tokmergenova for her help with communication and spreading the open call.
The City of Settlers Workshop
Workshop program City of Settlers explored Bishkek’s diverse history, focusing on the migrant experiences of those who have shaped Pishpek, Frunze, and Bishkek. Among them were settled (semi-)nomads, peasants, refugees, evacuees, deportees, factory workers, and students.

Participants were invited to reflect on their journey to Kyrgyzstan's capital while also exploring the microhistories of other residents, uncovering what it meant to be a newcomer to Bishkek at different times. Participants engaged in self-reflective discussions, participated in role-playing activities, and created an imaginary museum of migration, showcasing an array of migration stories.

The workshop City of Settlers took place on November 23, November 30, and December 7.


I would like to express my gratitude to the bookstore "Knizhnaya Lavka" and its owners Anara Moldosheva and Charlie Buxton for generously providing us with the space. I also sincerely thank Alima Tokmergenova for her help with communication and spreading the open call.
Behind City of Settlers project
Lilit Dabagian
Educational project developer, trainer and multimedia zine creator
Lilit Dabagian is originally from Bishkek but currently lives in Berlin. She is a public history practitioner and designer of multimedia educational projects with a distinct interest in (post-)socialist experiences, urban memory spaces, and migration.

You can learn more about her projects here
Lilit Dabagian
Educational project developer, trainer and multimedia zine creator
Lilit Dabagian is originally from Bishkek but currently lives in Berlin. She is a public history practitioner and designer of multimedia educational projects with a distinct interest in (post-)socialist experiences, urban memory spaces, and migration.

You can learn more about her projects here
Dr. David Leupold
Guest speaker and academic advisor
Dr. David Leupold is a Berlin-based sociologist and the author of the award-winning book Embattled Dreamlands (2020). As a scholar of memory studies and the politics of history, he supported the project City of Settlers as an academic advisor and knowledge mediator.
Dr. David Leupold
Guest speaker and academic advisor
Dr. David Leupold is a Berlin-based sociologist and the author of the award-winning book Embattled Dreamlands (2020). As a scholar of memory studies and the politics of history, he supported the project City of Settlers as an academic advisor and knowledge mediator.
This Story is not over,,,
Would you like to contribute to the project?
This Story is not over,,,
Would you like to contribute to the project?
If you want to share your migration story, please write to us on Instagram. City of Settlers is a platform that aims to document the ongoing migration history to Bishkek.
If you want to share your migration story, please write to us on Instagram. City of Settlers is a platform that aims to document the ongoing migration history to Bishkek.

All text and photo materials belong to their respective owners.
Made on
Tilda